How to review ?

What to review ?

• You can publish reviews about any Web documents (HTML pages, PDF files, images, ...). The only requirement is know the URL of this document.
• You may have as many review as you want. Nevertheless, you can have only one review on the same URL.
• Once published, you can re-edit this review to change any fields (comment, rating, categories, ...)
• At any time, you can remove one of your review

Some advises to review

• URL

  • Prefer 1-Click Review to automatically fill the URL field
  • Otherwise, use the precise URL of the document to review (prefer copy/past to avoid typo)
  • If there are severals URL for the document to review (e.g. mirrors), prefer the original one
  • Avoid contextual or transient URL

• Title

  • Prefer 1-Click Review to automatically fill the title field
  • Prefer the real title of the document, except if the title is meaningless, inaccurate or too long.

• Rating

  • Choose the ratings as you feel: we are looking for subjective reviews !
  • Try to keep coherent the way you attribute ratings.
  • Try to use the full range of available rating.

• Comment

  • Use the terms that may be used in a full text search.
  • Feel free to give a subjective review.
  • A comment may contain HTML tag. There is no check, avoid to make a mistake.

• Categories

  • If this is the first review for this page, you have to select relevant categories. When other reviews have been published on this URL, proposed categories are selected from these reviews.
  • Use the more precise categories available.
  • Avoid to select the parents of a selected category.
  • Use multiple categories. Typically one category for the type of the document (article, book, FAQ, ...) and one for the topic (JDBC, Swing, ...).
  • Avoid to use too many categories.
  • If you feel the correct category doesn't exist, send a suggestion by mail to the channel administrator.

Property

• All the reviews are the property of the channel service operator.
• The reviews are also the property of their author who may publish the same data otherwhere on any media electronic or not.

Responsability

• The author of a review is the only one person responsible for what he or she has said.
• Althought the administrator is not responsible for the personal opinion expressed, he has the right to "moderate" the channel to raise the quality of the channel.

Moderation

• A moderator may remove your review if it doesn't match the channel purpose or if it is against the law.
• A moderator may also edit your review to fix any kind of mistake (typos, too many categories,...)